Group vs Private Swimming Lessons for Kids: Which Is Right for Your Child?

If you’re looking for swimming lessons in Singapore for your child, you’ve likely seen two main options: private lessons and group classes. Both can be effective, but they work better for different kids depending on their needs.

This guide will help you understand the differences between group and private lessons so you can make a decision that’s right for your family and kids.

Table of Contents

What Are Group Lessons Actually Like?

In a group swimming class your child will learn with a few other kids. There are usually four to six students in a class with one coach. 

The good thing about group classes is that your child will be with kids. They can watch each other try things and cheer each other on. This can help your child try harder than they would on their own.  Plus, group classes usually follow a structured curriculum, like the SwimSafer program, which is recognized by Sport Singapore and widely used in schools. This means parents will have a clear idea of their child’s progress.

The problem with group classes is that they have to move at a pace that is good for everyone. So, if your child needs a little extra time to get comfortable with floating, the session won’t slow down for them. This approach generally suits kids who’re comfortable in the water, outgoing and steady learners. But for kids who may be feeling nervous, this approach could slow their progress and create frustration over time.

What About Private Lessons?

Private swimming lessons focus solely on your child, with just one coach for the entire session. At Swimwerks, each lesson lasts about 45 minutes, and the coach starts by assessing your child’s comfort level and skills. This means the session is tailored to what your child needs right then and there. If they’re struggling with something, the coach can slow down and focus on it.

This personalized approach is crucial.  Research from the American Swimming Coaches Association shows that immediate and specific feedback is key to helping young swimmers develop their skills faster.

Private lessons are also great for kids who need to catch up before joining a group or for those who are preparing for the SwimSafer assessment. There’s no one else around to create social pressure, and the coach can go at a pace that makes your child feel safe. Many kids who did not do well in group classes did better when they switched to private lessons.

A Simple Way to Decide

If you’re still unsure, here’s a straightforward breakdown to help guide your decision:

Go with private lessons if your child:

  • Is scared of the water
  • Has never swum before
  • Had a bad experience in a class before
  • Needs to develop specific skills or get ready for an assessment
  • Learns better and feels more comfortable with one on one guidance  

Go with group lessons if your child:

  • Is comfortable in the water 
  • Enjoys being around other kids and learns well in a social setting
  • Can learn new things quickly 
  • Is making progress in the SwimSafer program with other kids 

Start with private, then switch to group if your child:

  • Is a bit anxious but eager to try new things
  • Is a complete beginner but shows interest in learning
  • Needs some confidence before stepping into a larger class environment

Understanding the Cost: Is Private Swimming Coaching Worth It?

Private swimming lessons are definitely pricier than group classes, and that’s just something to keep in mind. The upside is you get the coach’s full focus for the entire session.

The real question is what your child needs. If your kid is nervous about being in the water, they might struggle more in a group setting. In that case, a few private lessons at first could actually save you money in the long run by helping them gain confidence quicker before moving to group classes.

Many parents at Swimwerks start their kids with private lessons for a couple of months to build confidence and essential skills before transitioning to group sessions. This approach often combines the benefits of both types of lessons.

group vs private swimming lessons singapore

What Swimwerks Recommends

At Swimwerks, our coaches are well-trained and certified in multiple swimming instruction programs, and all of them hold valid First Aid certificates. When you come to us, the first thing we do is assess your child’s water confidence and skill level. This way, we provide you with advice that’s tailored to your child’s specific needs rather than just pushing a sales pitch.

Generally, we find that kids who are new to swimming or are scared should start with lessons. Once they feel more comfortable they can join a group class. We offer classes at ActiveSG pools and various condominiums around the island, so finding a convenient place for lessons is usually not a hassle.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my child switch from private to group lessons later?

Yes, children can easily transition from private to group classes later on, and it’s quite common at Swimwerks.

It really varies. Some kids might be ready after six to eight sessions, while others might need more time. Your coach will provide a clear assessment after the first few lessons.

We welcome children from the age of four.

In most cases, yes! Having the coach’s full attention allows them to work at a comfortable pace without the stress of being compared to others. We’ve seen many kids who started off nervous make significant progress through private coaching.

We conduct them at ActiveSG pools throughout Singapore and at condos across the island. If you have a private pool, our coaches can come to you as well.

If you want to find out what’s best for your child, feel free to contact the Swimwerks team or give us a call at +65 8886 3021 for a straightforward recommendation based on their current skill level.

Enquiry Form