When it comes to improving your swimming technique and building strength, swim fins are a practical and widely used training tool. They enhance your capabilities in the water by targeting specific muscles, improving body positioning, and helping you focus on your kicking technique.
However, the choice between short fins and long fins can leave swimmers uncertain about which option best suits their needs. Both types of fins have unique characteristics that make them suitable for different purposes, and choosing between them depends on your swimming goals, whether you aim to enhance power, endurance, or technique.
Short fins are characterised by compact blades extending only a few centimetres beyond the toes. This streamlined design mimics the natural motion of swimming without fins, making them an excellent choice for swimmers looking to refine their technique.
Unlike their longer counterparts, which provide more resistance and propulsion, short fins prioritise control and faster kicking, allowing swimmers to maintain a tempo similar to what they would use in a real swimming scenario.
Short fins are especially beneficial for those working on technique. They encourage proper body alignment and allow swimmers to focus on the precision of their movements without relying on the added propulsion that long fins provide. This makes short fins a great choice for improving overall swimming.
Overall, short fins are ideal for developing speed, strength, and technical skills, making them a versatile option for swim training.
True to their name, long fins feature extended blades that stretch significantly farther from the foot compared to short fins. Their design resembles snorkelling fins, with larger blades that create noticeable resistance when moving through the water.
This resistance makes long fins an excellent choice for swimmers looking to strengthen their lower body muscles and improve their overall kicking technique.
One key benefit of long fins is their ability to help swimmers develop a better “feel” for the water. The added propulsion provided by the longer blades allows swimmers to focus on their form and body positioning without exerting as much effort to move forward. For those looking to master the basics of swimming, long fins are great for practice.
Long fins are also highly effective at enhancing ankle flexibility, which is crucial for efficient kicking. The extended motion required by these fins encourages a full range of movement in the ankles, helping swimmers improve their kick efficiency over time. This can be especially beneficial for those who struggle with stiff ankles or improper kicking mechanics.
Pros:
Cons:
Pros:
Cons:
Each fin comes with its own distinct advantages and properties. Knowing your swimming goals is important when choosing the right fin for the job. Here are some factors to consider.
One of the most critical factors when selecting fins is your training objectives. Short fins are likely the better option if you’re looking to improve speed, maintain a natural kicking rhythm, or sharpen your technique. Their designs mimic real-world swimming conditions, helping you refine your form.
On the other hand, long fins are ideal for building strength and endurance. Their extended blades provide more resistance, allowing you to focus on controlled, deliberate movements that develop power and stamina.
Long fins often benefit beginners by providing extra propulsion to move them forward, making it easier for them to move through the water. This added support helps new swimmers focus on proper kicking form and body positioning without feeling overwhelmed.
However, more experienced swimmers may prefer the precision and challenge that short fins offer. These fins demand more effort and control, which can help seasoned swimmers fine-tune their performance.
Different fins cater to specific workout styles. Short fins are advantageous for sprinting or high-intensity training, as they support rapid kicking while enhancing strength and endurance.
Long fins, by contrast, are better suited for endurance-focused sessions or drills that prioritise steady, controlled movements. Basically, short fins are for sprinting, and long fins are for marathons.
If your workouts vary, incorporating both types of fins into your routine can offer a well-rounded approach.
Improving ankle flexibility is another important consideration. Long fins are particularly effective in this area, encouraging a greater range of motion with each kick. This is ideal for swimmers who struggle with stiffness or limited ankle flexibility.
While short fins don’t provide as much flexibility training, they focus more on strength and control, making them a good choice for swimmers prioritising muscle development and lower body strength.
Of course, we need to talk about comfort. A tool is only helpful if it feels right for you. Both short and long fins are designed to fit snugly without causing irritation or discomfort. When trying on fins, pay attention to how they feel around your toes, heels, and arches.
Short and long fins come in various shapes and materials, so take the time to explore different options. Some swimmers prefer fins with soft foot pockets for added comfort, while others opt for a more rigid structure for better control. Whichever type you choose, remember that a poorly fitting fin can hinder your performance and even lead to blisters.
Take the time to consider these aspects, but don’t get too hung up about the details or efficiency. At the end of the day, swimming is meant to be enjoyable and a way to destress. If a fin feels right for you, then go for it!
One of the most important considerations when choosing between short and long fins is how they adapt to different swimming strokes. Each fin type brings unique benefits to specific strokes, helping swimmers improve technique, strength, and efficiency.
Freestyle (Front Crawl)
Short fins are great for freestyle training because they encourage a natural and quick kicking motion. The compact design allows swimmers to maintain a high kick tempo, essential for improving speed and efficiency in freestyle swimming. They are ideal for practising quick, flutter kicks that mimic how you would swim without fins.
Long fins, on the other hand, focus on building strength and endurance in freestyle. The increased resistance provided by the longer blades helps swimmers work on a steady and controlled kick, making them perfect for endurance-focused freestyle drills.
Backstroke
Short fins are great for enhancing leg speed and maintaining a consistent rhythm in the backstroke. They also help swimmers concentrate on maintaining proper body alignment, as the shorter blades make it easier to feel the water and correct any imbalances.
Long fins in backstroke training help build a stronger, more powerful kick. They also help beginners or those looking to build confidence, as the added propulsion can make the stroke feel smoother and less strenuous.
Butterfly
Short fins are the preferred choice for butterfly training because they allow swimmers to focus on the quick, powerful dolphin kick required for this stroke. The shorter blades don’t slow down the tempo, making them ideal for developing speed and precision.
Long fins can still be helpful for butterfly training, particularly for those working on mastering the stroke. They provide added lift and propulsion, which can aid in learning the undulating motion of the butterfly kick. However, they may limit the speed at which the kick is performed.
Breaststroke
Short fins are less commonly used in breaststroke training, as the natural movement of the stroke doesn’t require constant flutter or dolphin kicks. However, they can be used in drills focusing on building leg strength or for crossover exercises combining breaststroke arms with dolphin kicks.
Long fins are also not traditionally associated with breaststroke, but they may occasionally be used for improving general leg strength and endurance in mixed-stroke training.
Drills and Stroke-Specific Adaptability
Both short and long fins can be incorporated into stroke-specific drills to target specific areas of improvement:
Use short fins for high-speed drills, where maintaining a natural stroke rhythm is crucial.
Use long fins for strength-building drills that require controlled, deliberate movements.
Although swim fins help improve technique, build strength, and enhance endurance, improper use can lead to missed opportunities for growth or even discomfort. Both short and long fins have their unique challenges, and being mindful of these common mistakes can help swimmers get the most out of their training.
A common mistake swimmers make is relying too much on fins for every workout. While fins are fantastic for training, overusing them can lead to dependency on the extra advantages they provide.
This can prevent swimmers from developing their natural kicking strength and rhythm, which is necessary for fin-free swimming. Balance and alternate fin and non-fin sessions are key.
Another common mistake is choosing fins that don’t align with your objectives. For example, long fins for sprint training or short fins for endurance drills can undermine your progress.
As we discussed, long fins are ideal for building strength and mastering controlled movements, while short fins excel in speed-focused training and technique refinement. Always match your fin type to the purpose of your workout.
Poorly fitting fins can cause more harm than good. Loose fins can slip off mid-swim, interrupting your workout, while overly tight fins can lead to blisters, pinching, or restricted movement. Take the time to find fins that fit snugly but comfortably, and test them in the water before committing. A good fit ensures the fins work with you, not against you.
It’s easy to let fins do the work for you, but this can lead to bad habits. Swimmers often neglect proper form when using fins, assuming the propulsion will compensate for poor technique. This can result in improper body alignment, lazy kicks, or inefficient arm movements. When using fins, prioritise technique to ensure skills transfer seamlessly to fin-free swimming.
If not used mindfully, both short and long fins can encourage incorrect kicking patterns. With short fins, swimmers may over-kick, leading to wasted energy.
On the other hand, long fins can promote exaggerated, slow kicks that disrupt the natural flow of the stroke. Swimmers should aim for a consistent, efficient kick tailored to their stroke type, regardless of fin length.
Long fins are excellent for improving ankle flexibility, but swimmers must actively work on achieving a full range of motion to reap this benefit. Similarly, short fins require good ankle flexibility to maintain proper form. Failing to address this aspect can lead to strain or stiffness, limiting overall performance gains.
Relying on fins to maintain speed or balance can prevent swimmers from addressing weak areas in their technique. For example, relying on fins to stay afloat may mask poor body positioning or insufficient kick strength. Use fins as a supplemental tool, not a replacement for developing fundamental swimming skills.
Jumping straight into a fin workout without warming up can strain unprepared muscles while skipping a cool-down without fins can leave you overly dependent on their assistance. Include fin-free warm-ups and cool-downs to maintain a natural feel for the water.
Long fins are great for low-intensity recovery sessions, allowing swimmers to maintain fitness while reducing strain. However, many swimmers neglect this opportunity and miss out on active recovery benefits. Incorporating fins into gentle recovery swims can promote relaxation and prevent burnout.
Proper maintenance of equipment is often neglected. If not cared for, chlorine, saltwater, and wear and tear can degrade fin materials. Rinse fins thoroughly after each use and store them in a cool, dry place to maintain their condition and extend their lifespan.
Choosing between short and long fins for swimming depends on your specific goals. Short fins are ideal for refining technique and improving speed, while long fins excel in building strength and mastering controlled movements.
If you’re unsure which fin suits your needs, consider what aspects of swimming you’re trying to improve. Both options offer unique benefits, so incorporating both into your routine may offer the best of both worlds.
Alternatively, why not work with Swimwerks? Whether you are an experienced swimmer or just starting out, Swimwerks offers private lessons to help you choose the right fins and achieve your swimming goals.
Contact us and start flipping your fins today!
Swim fins help beginners build confidence, improve kicking form, and make swimming less tiring by providing additional propulsion.
While not necessary, swim fins can make learning easier by providing extra buoyancy and propulsion, especially for new swimmers who are building their confidence.
It’s often better to start with long fins as they provide extra propulsion, making it easier for beginners to focus on proper form and confidence.
Short fins are better for refining stroke efficiency as they simulate a natural swim pace, encouraging proper technique.
As your strength and technique improve, switch from long fins to short fins, transitioning to more advanced training drills that require precise movements.
Fins, particularly short ones, can enhance advanced stroke drills by promoting proper alignment, kick rhythm, and a more efficient pull phase.
